8 Underrated Horror Movies That Are Actually Scary

Underrated Horror Movies That Are Actually Scary: Of course, the most popular horror movies tend to get all the attention. The usual blockbusters, franchises, and trending movies. However, if you look deeper, there are some horror movies that provide real thrills, chills, and horror without getting the attention they deserve.

If you’re sick of jump scares and the same old horror movie tropes, then these movies provide something a lot more frightening. Here are 8 Underrated Horror Movies That Are Actually Scary.

1. The Autopsy of Jane Doe

In a morgue in rural Virginia, a father-son team of coroners is given an enigmatic corpse of an unknown woman (Jane Doe). She is seemingly unscathed on the outside, but as an autopsy is conducted, more and more inexplicable and horrific revelations come to light, from her wounds to evidence of her being alive. The morgue becomes a nightmarish environment. The movie has a unsettling tension through out that will keep you hooked to your seat.

Full NameThe Autopsy of Jane Doe
Year of Release2016
GenreSupernatural Horror / Mystery
CastEmile Hirsch, Brian Cox, Ophelia Lovibond
Where to WatchNetflix, Amazon Prime
IMDb Rating6.8/10

8 Underrated Horror Movies That Are Actually Scary
Underrated Horror Movies That Are Actually Scary

2. It Follows

Jay finds that after a seemingly innocent romantic encounter, she has fallen victim to a curse that causes a supernatural entity to slowly walk towards its victim, never running and never stopping. The horror of this entity comes in that it can take on any form and that there is no escape. The title it self suggests the deep psychological paranoia of being followed.

Full NameIt Follows
Year of Release2014
GenreSupernatural Horror / Psychological Thriller
CastMaika Monroe, Keir Gilchrist, Daniel Zovatto
Where to WatchAmazon Prime
IMDb Rating6.8/10

8 Underrated Horror Movies That Are Actually Scary
Underrated Horror Movies That Are Actually Scary

3. The Invitation

A man goes to a dinner party thrown by his ex-wife. Things seem off from the beginning, but they get stranger and stranger until the man becomes suspicious. It all builds up to a really creepy moment. It’s not gory or anything like that. It’s just awkward social situations and a sense of paranoia. This is a psychological discomfort horror with a emotionally gripping narrative.

Full NameThe Invitation
Year of Release2015
GenrePsychological Thriller / Horror
CastLogan Marshall-Green, Tammy Blanchard, Michiel Huisman
Where to WatchAmazon Prime
IMDb Rating6.6/10

8 Underrated Horror Movies That Are Actually Scary
Underrated Horror Movies That Are Actually Scary

4. Oculus

Two siblings set out to prove that a mysterious antique mirror was the cause of destruction in their family. As they confront the mirror, reality is distorted and they experience hallucinations and mental terror.

Full NameOculus
Year of Release2013
GenreSupernatural / Psychological Horror
CastKaren Gillan, Brenton Thwaites
Where to WatchAmazon Prime
IMDb Rating6.6/10

8 Underrated Horror Movies That Are Actually Scary
Underrated Horror Movies That Are Actually Scary

5. The Night House

As she tries to cope with her husband’s sudden death, she finds out some unsettling secrets in their lakeside home. As she delves deeper, her grief combines with psychological horror, leading to very eerie findings.

Full NameThe Night House
Year of Release2020
GenrePsychological / Supernatural Horror
CastRebecca Hall
Where to WatchAmazon Prime
IMDb Rating 6.4/10

8 Underrated Horror Movies That Are Actually Scary
Underrated Horror Movies That Are Actually Scary

6. The Dark and the Wicked

A brother and sister return to their ailing father’s farmhouse in the country, but they soon face a profoundly unsettling and malevolent force. The film is a masterclass in building dread with silence, despair, and mental terror, and it never really lets up.

Full NameThe Dark and the Wicked
Year of Release2020
GenrePsychological / Supernatural Horror
CastMarin Ireland, Michael Abbott Jr.
Where to WatchAmazon Prime
IMDb Rating6.1/10

Underrated Horror Movies That Are Actually Scary

7. The Taking of Deborah Logan

Documentary-style, the story is about a group of students who document the activities of an old woman named Deborah Logan who is suffering from Alzheimer’s. As the story progresses, the documentary takes a completely different turn from what was anticipated.

Deborah’s behavior is erratic and violent. She possesses physical strength beyond her years and her speech is abnormal. As the students document her activities, they get a shocking revelation that takes the documentary from bad to worse.

Full NameThe Taking of Deborah Logan
Year of Release2014
GenreFound Footage / Psychological / Supernatural Horror
CastJill Larson, Anne Ramsay, Michelle Ang
Where to WatchNetflix, Amazon Prime, Apple TV
IMDb Rating6.0/10

8 Underrated Horror Movies That Are Actually Scary
8 Underrated Horror Movies That Are Actually Scary

The Ritual

A group of friends embark on a hike through a remote forest in Scandinavian wilderness following the tragic death of their friend. The tension of survival is replaced by something much more sinister as the story unfolds. Lost in the wilderness, the friends come face to face with strange symbols, eerie structures, and an unseen force lurking in the woods. The tension rises to a chilling combination of psychological horror and ancient folklore terror. The tension is built slowly, yet relentlessly.

Full NameThe Ritual
Year of Release2017
GenrePsychological / Folk / Supernatural Horror
CastRafe Spall, Arsher Ali, Robert James-Collier
Where to WatchNetflix
IMDb Rating6.4/10

8 Underrated Horror Movies That Are Actually Scary

Summing Up

True horror movies are not to be found in mainstream cinema; they are to be found in movies that dare to experiment. The underrated horror movies are not more scary just because they are louder, but they are more scary because they are more intimate, more unpredictable, and more emotionally disturbing. These movies show that true horror movies are not about formulaic jump scares, but about tension that builds, ideas that disturb, and stories that refuse to take the well-trodden path. For those looking for horror movies that have more substance, these movies have more to offer than just publicity – they have horror that lasts.

For more celebrity biographies, struggle-to-success stories, and the latest entertainment updates, keep exploring Hit Bios and our partner site Vrl News.

More for you to read-

8 Shows Like “Wednesday” That You Should Watch Next

Similar Posts